Thursday, 28 November 2013

Too important to fail

Writing quite recently about demand in the US for ‘gigabit networks’, I reported one very credible view that the phenomenon reflects recognition of our growing reliance on the internet for all manner of infrastructure and services.  The proponent in question went on to explain: “that reliance is only going to increase and people will continue to want faster and faster broadband speeds for peace of mind.”  That begins to sound like an unhealthy spiral of addiction but is our growing dependence on communication networks (perversely) a ‘good thing’?  Well, it might be…

Earlier this month, a US court ruled that the Department of Homeland Security must make a plan to shut off the internet and mobile communications available to the American public. While President Obama quickly condemned former Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak for turning off the internet in his country to quell widespread civil disobedience in 2011, the US government apparently has the authority to do much the same thing - under a plan devised during the Bush administration. Details of the controversial "kill switch" authority have been classified but thanks to a Freedom of Information Act lawsuit filed by the Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC), DHS is obliged to reveal these within the next few months. 

Even assuming President Obama (or David Cameron) wanted to invoke such a measure, would it actually work?  Happily, the expert view seems to be that activating any kind of kill switch would do more harm than good.  According to Harold Feld, Vice President at Public Knowledge, a US lobby group focused on communications and technology policy, "I find it hard to imagine why an internet kill switch would ever be a good idea, short of some science fiction scenario wherein the network comes alive à la Terminator/Skynet.  At this point, so much of our critical infrastructure runs on the internet that a 'kill switch' would do more harm than anything short of a nuclear strike.  It would be like cutting off our own head to escape someone pulling our hair”.  A very similar argument is thought to apply to disabling mobile phones. The benefit of people being able to communicate on their cellphones in times of crisis is enormous, and cutting that off would potentially be very dangerous.  

At a time of growing concern about government security and surveillance issues, it’s heartening to find that the ubiquity of modern communications networks might actually be proof against ‘big brother’ measures.

Friday, 22 November 2013

Hail, the new economic wonder drug!

Well aware of the sundry benefits of faster broadband (not least the vastly improved performance of i-player!) I was fascinated to read recently that it’s also just the thing to supercharge economic growth.  According to analysis commissioned by DCMS from a consortium led by SQW (with Cambridge Econometrics and Dr Pantelis Koutroumpis), government interventions to upgrade broadband connectivity are projected to return approximately ‘£20 in net economic impact for every £1 of public investment’.  Wow!    

Unsurprisingly, I was not alone in feeling a tad sceptical about this conclusion: 

“Basically, BDUK has been getting a lot of flak and bad press…so the DCMS thought they best pay someone to write a nice report bigging up how much its broadband investment is going to bolster the economy”. (Computer Weekly) 

“The government, perhaps keen to cut through all the negative press, commissioned its UK Broadband Impact Study  in what appears to be a vain attempt to search for some good news about BDUK”. (The Register)

Within the Report itself, however, SQW appear to be refreshingly honest about its findings: 

“While recognising that there are still gaps in the empirical evidence base, and that the future is inherently uncertain, the study’s projections are the outputs from a rigorous and detailed analysis which draws on the best data currently available”. 

I was intrigued by that phrase, the ‘gaps in the empirical evidence base’, but it seems to stem largely from the Report’s later admission that: “The productivity impacts of increased speeds are, as yet, highly uncertain.” In fact, given the relatively recent introduction of high-speed broadband, SQW have had to invoke a labyrinth of tortuous logic and heroic assumptions to arrive at their central conclusion that: ‘an increase of 100% in the used speed in a year will lead to a 0.3% uplift in productivity  over the following three year period’. 

This sounds like a risky finding but, guess what…?
 “It also aligns…with research by Chalmers University of Technology, which found that a doubling of speed in OECD countries is associated with a 0.3 percentage point increase in GDP growth”.  What a coincidence!   

It turns out that the ‘research’ in question by Chalmers University (who??) consists of an econometric analysis of the past relationship between broadband speed and GDP growth in a sample of OECD countries.  A closer look at that analysis reveals this cautionary note from the authors: 

“This study concludes that the hypothetical impact of broadband speed on economic growth is statistically significant…. As the impact is modelled as linear, it needs to be judiciously applied when hypothetical country growth is far away from the sample means. The hypothetical impact is based on an elasticity measurement and any forward-looking simulation should be applied with care “. 

In other words, the past relationship established for this data set may not apply in the future for a different group…. As expected, therefore, take the ‘good news’ from DCMS with a pinch of salt.

Monday, 11 November 2013

Of broadband cats and pigeons

My goodness, what a flurry of feathers.… The Broadband Stakeholder Group (BSG) set out to conduct a perfectly sensible exercise, looking at the key statistical determinants of bandwidth requirement and how these determinants might change over the next ten years. Quite properly, they described this as “a model for forecasting bandwidth demand” but that choice of words may have been responsible for the subsequent furore and howls of protest when the ‘average demand’ turned out to be surprisingly low (19 Mbps).  For example, the FT reported that:

“A key government advisory group will raise questions over whether most homes in the UK are likely to need superfast broadband in 10 years’ time”.
Similarly, Sean Royce of Kingston Communications (KC) is reported as describing the BSG result as a 'red herring' that the Government might use as a ‘yard stick’ to help lower the bar for its own superfast broadband targets. 

The BSG has rightly defended its statistical results, and neither of the above policy claims would be justified, but I’m bound to agree with a further aspect of the criticism from Sean Royce, i.e.

“The second concern I have with the study is need versus desire. From our experience, there is a clear distinction between the broadband capacity that households need and the speed levels that consumers want. This isn’t simply about keeping up with the Jones’. It’s a recognition that…we [already] rely on the internet. That reliance is only going to increase and people will continue to want faster and faster broadband speeds for peace of mind.” 

Anyone in any doubt about the importance of broadband ‘aspiration’ need only consider the eruption in US demand for Gigabit capacity – probably sparked off by the pioneering deployment of Google fibre networks.  There is no shortage of editorial advice that ‘nobody needs gigabit capacity (yet!)’ but that hasn’t stopped the emergence of so-called gigabit envy.  The latest metropolitan examples are in Los Angeles and Las Vegas but there are now dozens of US cities planning Gigabit networks.  And the rhetoric isn’t confined to city mayors: earlier this year,
Julius Genachowski, then Chairman of the Federal Communications Commission, wrote an article entitled, ‘Why the U.S. Needs Gigabit Communities’.  It argued:

“We’re in a global bandwidth race, and we need to ensure the U.S. has a strategic bandwidth advantage. Without it, we risk losing our global lead on innovation, and we risk watching jobs and investment flow elsewhere….”

So much for the determinants of demand…

Tuesday, 29 October 2013

Hold the Champagne, boys…

Great news this month that every EU household now has access to basic broadband!  Well, that is if you include satellite coverage - which we didn’t before.  As Neelie Kroes says: 

“The EU is technology neutral, but for those in the most isolated areas, satellite is a good option to stay connected; and it's likely to remain so… Thanks to the extra coverage provided by satellite broadband, we have achieved our 2013 target of broadband for all. That's a great result for European citizens” 

As a reminder, ‘basic broadband for all’ was the first leg of the Digital Agenda for Europe (DAE) targets, i.e. 

·        Basic broadband (0.5-4Mbps) for all by 2013;

·        Next Generation Networks (30 Mbps or more) for all by 2020;

·        50% of households having 100 Mbps subscriptions or higher 

In the absence of satellite coverage, however, there is still some way to go before fixed networks of acceptable quality reach 100% of the population (the Universal Service Commitment in other words)..  At an EU level the same Press Release claims that fewer than 4% of citizens are denied access to fixed broadband but data released by Ofcom last week show that the equivalent UK figure is now hovering around 8%, i.e. 

Percentage of connections receiving
less than 2Mbit/s (June 2013) 

England                            8%
 
Scotland                            8%

Northern Ireland                12%

Wales                                12%

Total UK                          8% 

The good news is that these percentages have been falling pretty steadily over the past two years: the less positive story is that getting the figures down to zero may be more challenging than expected. We tend to assume that ‘citizens’ who have access to even relatively modest broadband improvement will grab it with both hands but the Ofcom Infrastructure Report suggests otherwise: 

“There are consumers on these slow lines who are in postcodes where NGA networks are available and, by upgrading their service, could receive much higher speeds.  When slow lines in postcodes where NGA is available are excluded, the percentage of connections operating at below 2Mbit/s reduces from 8% to just 3%”.  

Who are these people?  Why put up with an inadequate broadband service when a much better alternative is readily available?  Or is the real problem one of in-home wiring?  Whatever the reason, it’s evident that upgrading the infrastructure is only part of the battle.  Going back to Neelie’s Press Release, she was clearly wise to frame her celebration in terms of digital potential, i.e. 

“My motto is Every European Digital – now every European genuinely has the opportunity. We have more to do to improve networks and equalise the opportunity, but the opportunity is there.”

Friday, 11 October 2013

The levers of competition

In the classic debate about the most efficacious form of competition, infrastructure versus services, there was new evidence of support for both camps this week… 

First, for believers in service competition, who better to champion that cause than Dido Harding, CEO of TalkTalk?  Giving evidence to the PAC inquiry into the performance of BDUK (on 17th July), she said this: 

“I think that the infrastructure build is a natural monopoly…It’s the retail competition that really matters in this market” 

To be fair, Dido was speaking mostly about the copper broadband market but her emphasis on retail competition was borne out by the latest ITU rankings for Information Society performance. Helped largely by its intense retail competition, and correspondingly affordable internet access, the UK moved up from 12th to 8th in the ITU’s international league table.  

Speaking at the same PAC meeting in July, Nick James, CEO of UK Broadband, outlined why his own company had decided not to participate in the initial round of BDUK funding.   He cited the familiar explanations that the original BDUK funding areas had been too small and that BT had failed to identify the residual 10% for potential altnet coverage.  But what he had to say about infrastructure options was perhaps more enlightening.  The initial rules of the ‘competition had disallowed fixed wireless technology, thus excluding two potential bidders.  He went on to explain that, more significantly perhaps, the BDUK decision to reduce target superfast coverage from 100% to 90% had effectively played into BT’s hands: by allowing the feasibility of a single technology option, BT’s FTTC network, BDUK effectively removed the technology advantages an investment consortium could offer.  As he said: 

“Bidders planning to supply 100% [coverage] were disadvantaged against BT; the advantage a consortium could bring disappears…We were going to use a mix of technologies in order to get 100%: if you deploy multiple technologies, you can do more for less money…” 

This week’s hastily convened meeting by BDUK to discuss possible approaches for tackling the ‘final 10%’ may have proved to be something of a non-event but it did set out with the appearance of an open mind on the technology options – and the meeting’s invitation was extended to various wireless operators.  It remains to be seen whether these different technologies play any part in government-supported deployment of superfast broadband but there must be a realistic chance that the task will involve some kind of consortia – possibly including BT.  But in response to the Dido Harding camp, at least one thing is certain: the challenge of the final 10% cannot be met by retail competition.

Friday, 27 September 2013

Credit where it’s due

Hats off to Ed Vaizey and his colleagues for their notable triumph in media management… It was potentially such a juicy story: Margaret Hodge, still flushed with success from her attacks on tax evasion by major media corporates, was about to sink her teeth into both the government (DCMS) and BT for ‘ripping off Britain’.  Her conclusion as Chair of the PAC and its investigation into the BDUK fiasco had been scathing: 

“The programme to extend superfast broadband to rural areas has been mismanaged by the Department for Culture, Media and Sport. The sole provider BT has been placed in a quasi-monopolistic position which it is exploiting by restricting access to cost and roll-out information. The consumer is failing to get the benefits of healthy competition and BT will end up owning assets created from £1.2 billion of public money” 

The story did not receive universal coverage; The Times, for example, restricted it to a small paragraph on page 4. But the BBC decided to bill it as a major news item and lined up Ms Hodge against Ed Vaizey for the headline 'Today' interview on Radio 4 with John Humphrys at 8.10.  Hodge duly launched her rehearsed attacks on BT and government, and the scene was set for a ritual execution.  But the response strategy by Vaizey (and BT), a nice mixture of blunt denial and data obfuscation, was perfectly judged to kill the story stone dead.  Humphrys floundered.  The DCMS minister was therefore able to rebuff this and later BBC questioning with his head held high: 

“Well, we don’t agree with the report at all.  We think the broadband programme is fantastic; it’s very good value for money and it’s going to deliver broadband to millions of people living in rural areas who wouldn’t otherwise t get it” 

Give that man a coconut.

Friday, 6 September 2013

Beware blind alleys on the Superhighway

The European Commission issued a short 'memo' late last week that was admirable in a number of ways, i.e.
  • Its straightforward aim is to promote European investment in superfast networks.
  • Its language is clear and non-technical, as evidenced by the blunt title: “Regulatory mess hurting broadband investment”
  • Its policy prescriptions are correspondingly simple:
  • To create consistent copper unbundling opportunities – and prices – across the EU.
  • To harmonise the regulation of fibre networks (while maintaining flexibility in charging models) 
The mantra throughout the document is ‘predictability and consistency’.  In Neelie Kroes’ words, “It’s vital that all companies have a stable and consistent system. That is how we can maximise investment and the infrastructure competition that encourages investment.”  

Well, up to a point.  I can see that levelling unbundling prices – currently ranging across the EU from €4 to €14 per month – might just persuade the likes of Sky or TalkTalk to venture into Europe, and more consistency in fibre regulation would certainly do no harm, but where I slightly part company with Neelie is the presumption that the two broadband markets can be structurally linked, i.e. 

“If the [copper unbundling] price is too low this…reduces the incentive for ‘alternative operators’ to move from renting a network to building their own Next Generation network. This is a frequent problem today”. 

‘Frequent’?  Really?  How likely is it that a broadband operator will migrate from renting copper to building fibre?  No examples spring to mind and, intuitively, it’s hard to imagine a developer of FTTP having much interest in a copper solution (other than the incumbent, of course).  Even at the theoretical level, arguments that might link the two markets – such as the ‘ladder of investment hypothesis’ -have largely been discredited by economists in recent years.  For example: 

“The “ladder of investment” theory argues that it is good to promote intra-platform competition as a stepping stone for new entrants to induce them to invest. Our study shows there is no support for this theory, and that to the contrary intra-platform competition may even give adverse investment incentives. (Bouckaert et al). 

“Academics have not been very gentle with the ladder of investment approach, not only because the theory itself lacks logical fundamentals but also because empirical evidences tend not to support it” (Jund et al). 

Overall, there’s a lot to be welcomed in the memo’s intentions and regulatory objectives, particularly the recognition that the long pay-back times of broadband investment call for predictable prices and revenue streams.  But it would be a pity if the Commission came to rely too heavily on copper pricing as a determinant of new network investment.