Tuesday, 11 March 2014

A sad reflection

One of my few claims to fame is that I briefly knew Colette Bowe in a previous life – when she was, perhaps, rather less of the ‘grande dame’ of regulation that we know today.  I’ve therefore followed her subsequent career with interest and, now that that she has elected to leave the chairmanship of Ofcom, I wondered whether she might offer us some indiscrete remarks or other obiter dicta about her 5 years with the UK regulator.  No such luck of course but, courtesy of a recent blog by Roger Darlington, I did notice some interesting remarks she made in an interview at the close of the Oxford Media Convention.  In particular, she was asked about the public perception of Ofcom’s role – in the wake of David Cameron’s famous “Bonfire of the Quangos” speech in 2009 (announcing his intention that Ofcom would be stripped of its policy-making function). Colette apparently insisted that: 

  “Policy making is not our job” and that “Ofcom is the keeper of the facts”. 

Oh dear. The first statement may be the unfortunate reality but I didn’t realize that Ofcom’s emasculation had gone as far as the second. Doesn’t bode well for regulatory policy…

Wednesday, 26 February 2014

Seconds out, the internet gloves are finally off

Well, after many years of fretting about the net neutrality debate, I see that the combatants have now begun the move into battle formation.  Presumably encouraged by the FCC’s recent set-back in its attempt to enforce net neutrality principles, and the FCC chairman’s rather limp response,  Comcast has exploited the virtual vacuum by establishing something like ‘most favoured nation’ commercial terms with Netflix. 

There is no shortage of doom-mongers to proclaim that the (internet) sky is falling but, however controversially, I’d like to put forward a contrary, albeit rather simplistic hypothesis.  Another recent Washington Post article by Timothy Lee is right to focus on competitive dynamics in its analysis of how Comcast and Netflix reached this new negotiation but I would argue that an ISPs’ exercise of market power needs to be regarded in the same light.  Why does Comcast have market power over Netflix – and other content providers?  Simply because Comcast has chosen to invest in the – hitherto – least rewarding segment of the value chain, the local access network.  There is, in principle, nothing to prevent another player - or Netflix itself – exploiting these economic rents if it is prepared to make a similar long-term investment in infrastructure.  It won’t, of course, and the chances are that the wounded FCC will still find some way to minimise rent-seeking by the ISPs but the clash between these leading internet players may yet prove to have been a useful reminder of basic economics.

 

Tuesday, 18 February 2014

Steady as she goes?

After a good deal of reflection, I’ve slowly been coming round to the view that the UK’s ‘broadband experiment’ has been going pretty well – always assuming we’re content with the limited FTTC architecture mandated by BT. It came as little surprise, therefore, that a recent report led by Richard Cadman’s SPC Network on the future of regulation in EU telecoms markets was highly complimentary, e.g. 

“The European broadband story, like that of European telecommunications, is generally one of success.  Consumers have benefited materially from increasing broadband competition over the past ten years: access speeds have increased, retail prices have fallen, while choice has expanded and European consumers enjoy faster access speeds and lower prices than their American counterparts.….. The picture for investors and for investment in the industry in the EU is also a positive one”. 

Where I felt less comfortable with the report was in its affirmation of existing regulatory policy.  In particular:
 
“From our evidence-based review of the performance of the market to date we conclude that there is no case for an extensive overhaul of the current regulatory framework…. It is also our view that the ladder of investment remains a valid concept and is critical to the continued development of the market”. 

OK, I think we all accept that LLU has played a vital part in the diffusion of consumer broadband, and the report is careful to stress the importance of developing new forms of unbundling in an NGN environment, but I always thought the ladder of investment concept was about more than access to incumbent infrastructure…
Sure enough, digging around in Martin Cave’s original papers, I came across this:

“The ladder of investment approach articulated by Martin Cave in 2006 suggests that access regulation is not only pro-competitive per se as it reduces barriers to entry but also is an indirect device to promote facility-based competition” 

Happily, we’re seeing more and more examples of new network being developed, most of it fibre-based, but I’ve seen very little evidence that these new networks owe their origin to the report’s acclaimed ‘ladder of investment’ philosophy..
 

Sunday, 26 January 2014

Not neutrality

One of the surprises for me in the whole Snowden/surveillance/data security controversy is that, relatively speaking, it hasn’t created more angst on this side of the Atlantic. Perhaps for similar reasons, the net neutrality debate appears not to have engendered the same levels of outrage within the UK’s business and civil liberties camps. For my own part, I’ve resisted commenting over the past year or more because there seemed little new to add, given that the two factions were merely reiterating their already entrenched positions. But there was some real news earlier this month and I couldn’t resist commenting on some of the coverage. 

On 14th January, a U.S. Court struck down the most recent attempt by the FCC to enforce net neutrality rules – its so-called Open Internet Order. The court found that parts of these regulations violated the Communications Act's clear prohibition on imposing common carriage requirements on networks like the Internet. 

While many would argue that the court ruling actually propels the FCC towards a more sensible regulatory approach, several long-time champions of net neutrality reacted angrily.  For example, Tim Wu, a professor at Columbia Law School, wrote an article for the next day’s edition of The New Yorker entitled ‘Closing Time for the Open Internet’.  He wrote:

“Acting together, the Internet service providers could destroy Netflix by slowing its data to a crawl, making movies impossible to watch”.

The next week, another publication,The Register, reported as follows:

“Netflix – which has roughly 40 million subscribers globally – yesterday warned its investors (and the wider world) that cable companies and other ISPs could arbitrarily strangle access to online video sites or block them entirely unless, say, said websites coughed up some cash. If this were to happen, Netflix vowed it would unleash hell”. 

 So, a justifiable declaration of war by Netflix?  Well, not quite… The Netflix ‘warning to investors’ was contained in that week’s letter to shareholders by senior management.  This goes on to say:

“The most likely case, however, is that ISPs will avoid this consumer-unfriendly path of discrimination… ISPs are generally aware of the broad public support for net neutrality and don’t want to galvanize government action… Moreover, ISPs have very profitable broadband businesses they want to expand. Consumers purchase higher bandwidth packages mostly for one reason: high-quality streaming video”. 

Precisely, and the same point is actually reiterated later in the Tim Wu article:

“These days, Internet firms like Google and Facebook are so powerful that they could decide to turn around and demand that Internet providers pay them for the right to access their sites. This is the norm in cable television.” 

To my mind, the net neutrality debate might finally have become interesting!

 

Wednesday, 15 January 2014

Distance is dead: long live distance!

‘Christmas is a time for families’ goes the saying, and, like many parents, I was again grateful this year that Skype made it possible for me to see and talk to my far-flung children over the festive season.  OK there was a bit of delay in speech now and then but, when a call to the other side of the world is totally free, who’s complaining about quality of service? 

In fact, being aware of the fast broadband connections in use at the far end, I had always assumed that any problems in call quality arose simply because of the limited DSL service available from BT in my home village.  However, a recent article in the US publication, Techpolicy Daily, has shed more light on this.  The article explains that even digital transmission of data requires the signal to be boosted periodically along the length of the transmission line.  Each such boost imposes a miniscule delay and, the more boosts, the greater the travel time impediment.  This cumulative deterioration in latency is independent of any delays resulting from local access speeds.  In other words: 

“Even if all users access the internet over connections offering the same speed, data will take longer to reach those located more distant from its origin”. 

Does this matter?  Perhaps not in the case of my Skype calls but, as the article goes on to explain, it could have a bearing on the uptake of centralized data repositories, such as those needed for cloud computing, particularly in physically distant and less densely-populated locations like New Zealand.  

Oops!  It’s another digital divide…

Wednesday, 18 December 2013

Me and my shadow

I don’t often write about the negative impacts of ‘the wired world’ but I’ve recently been prompted to do so by my preparations for Christmas.  As is well known, Britain is the biggest online shopping nation in the developed world, with almost two-thirds of adults using the internet to buy goods or services.  I have followed that fine tradition by doing all my Christmas shopping on-line, and I’ve been very happy with my purchases, but what has made me less happy is the visible ‘audit trail’ that these transactions have left.  Every time I log on to a well-known electronic retailer, I am presented with pictorial information on the items I have purchased, the items I might have purchased - and the items my wife bought.  So much for surprises! 

Now, I realize that the audit trails should probably be seen as a benign and inevitable part of the on-line experience, and I’m told that there are ways to disguise buying information, but the experience got me thinking about other ways an on-line presence could easily become intrusive.  The hazards of social media are well understood but what about the prospective ‘internet of things?  Do I really want someone (or something) else to know where I go with my smartphone or what time I go to bed…? 

This is essentially a network security and surveillance problem.  I don’t have the technical expertise to suggest its resolution but I’m glad to see that better-equipped people – such as Glyn Moody – are starting to worry about the same issue.  I wonder if he could advise on Santa’s Dilemma…?  

Thursday, 12 December 2013

‘Tis the season for giving

Whoa, can this be true?  Yet more money for broadband infrastructure?  OK, the latest (Autumn Statement) gift from the government - £10m for a ‘competitive fund’ to address coverage in remote rural areas – was really pretty modest, but just consider the investment already made: £530m for the original BDUK endowment; a further £250 allocated from the 2013 spending round; £150m for ‘Super-connected Cities’ (still- born but the subsequent voucher scheme is valuable nonetheless); £150m for improved mobile coverage etc. etc.  It all adds up to a tidy sum, and one nicely garnished with the latest upbeat opinions of research firm Point Topic: 

“95% [superfast coverage] by 2017 should certainly be achievable and is also desirable…In fact, with the inclusion of FWA, mobile and satellite in the metrics, the targets can in some senses said to have already been achieved” 

So, notwithstanding some recurring criticism of BT’s commercial tactics, the UK broadband outlook appears remarkably encouraging - and showing signs that the government’s drip-feed of subsidies is beginning to pay off. Enjoy the moment!  

It’s a pity, therefore, that some new research from the US shows Europe’s broadband investment is actually falling well behind.  Based on detailed CAPEX data compiled by Infonetics, Roslyn Layton of Aalborg University in Copenhagen has compared recent broadband investment levels in the US with that of the aggregate spend by the 27 EU states. Her results are summarized below.
 
2011
CAPEX
billions
2012
CAPEX
billions
YoY
Change
2011
Population
millions
2011
$/pers
2012
Population
millions
2012
$/pers
US
$72.4
$77.6
7%
311.6
$232
313.9
$247
EU27
$63.4
$50.3
-21%
501.9
$126
500.0
$100
As the table shows, Europe’s per capita investment in 2011 was already little more than half that of the US; worse, the 7% downturn in the EU’s spending last year meant that it was spending only 40 cents on broadband equipment for every dollar invested in the US.   
Now, there is clearly a ‘political’ agenda behind this research, and one might question whether the apparently superior US investment has resulted in such a vibrant broadband market, but it seems fair to conclude that any “best in Europe” claim by the UK might actually amount to a rather hollow victory.